I've made the deviled-eyeball eggs. I've made the hot-dog fingers. I once spent three hours on a "brain Jell-O mold" that looked like a pink cow pie. Here's what I learned: creepy snacks need two things — a name and one gross detail. Beyond that, keep it cheap and easy or you'll hate yourself by the time guests arrive.
Ten recipes that hit both. None take more than 15 minutes of active work.
1. Severed Finger Hot Dogs
Boil hot dogs. Cut a fingernail-shaped slit near one end, stick an almond slice on for the nail. Ketchup at the cut end for blood. Done. Kids lose their minds over these. $4 for a pack of Nathans and you're feeding 20.
2. Deviled Eyeballs
Deviled eggs. Add a green olive slice in the center of each yolk. A dot of red food coloring around the edges gives you bloodshot lines. Looks like an eye. Tastes like an egg. Cost: $3 for a dozen.
3. Mummy Hot Dogs
Crescent roll dough wrapped around hot dogs, leaving a gap for "eyes" — two mustard dots. Bake at 375 for 12 minutes. Pillsbury crescent rolls are $3, hot dogs $4. Always the first thing gone at my parties. Always.
4. Spider Web Dip
Layer refried beans, guacamole, and sour cream in a shallow bowl. Pipe black olive tapenade or barbecue sauce in a web pattern on top. Put a plastic spider on it. Kids eat it before noticing the spider is fake. About $8 in ingredients and feeds a crowd.
5. Boogers on a Stick
Pretzel rods dipped in green candy melts, with sprinkles pressed in while wet. Looks disgusting. Tastes like white chocolate. Dollar Tree green melts are $1.25 and one bag covers 20 rods. My 9-year-old named these and I can't un-name them.
6. Bloody Popcorn
Popcorn tossed in melted butter with a few drops of red food coloring. Put it in a black bowl. Looks like a crime scene, tastes like movie popcorn. This one is free if you already have popcorn in the pantry.
7. Cheese Fingers
String cheese sticks cut in half, with a bit of bell pepper for a fingernail and a sliced almond at the tip. Arranged on a plate to look like a pile of fingers. String cheese is $5 for a 12-pack at Walmart. Looks worse than it tastes, which is the whole goal.
want the good stuff monthly?
one short email, no spam.
8. Ghost Bananas
Banana halves standing up, chocolate chips for eyes and a mouth. Stick a popsicle stick in the bottom. That's it. Looks like a tiny ghost army. Three dollars in bananas and kids think you're a genius.
9. Worms in Dirt
Chocolate pudding cups with crushed Oreos on top and gummy worms poking out. This is the laziest snack on earth and kids request it by name every year. Jell-O pudding cups are $3 for six, Oreos $4, gummy worms $2. Under $10 and it disappears.
10. Witch Hat Cookies
Fudge Stripe cookies flipped upside down, a Hershey kiss in the center, icing band around the kiss. Looks like a witch hat. Keebler Fudge Stripe cookies are $3, Hershey kisses $4, icing $2. About 25 hats for $9.
What to Skip
- Any snack that requires a mold. Brain molds, skull molds, hand molds — they never come out right and they take three hours to set. You'll spend the party apologizing for it while it sweats on the table.
- Fondant. It's expensive, it tastes like sweet cardboard, and you're decorating a Rice Krispie treat. Nobody over the age of six is impressed.
- Anything labeled "gourmet" online. The $14 "crawling roach" chocolates on Amazon taste the same as the $4 bag from Dollar Tree. Buy the cheap ones.
The Rule
One gross detail per snack. Eyeballs have an olive. Fingers have a nail. Worms have a worm. Pile on three gross details and it stops being creepy and starts being confusing. Restraint is what makes Halloween food land.
Total cost for all ten: under $40 if you buy smart. Feeds 15-20 kids and their parents. And you didn't spend the party hiding in the kitchen.
