The father-in-law who "has everything" is the hardest person on the list. He buys what he wants when he wants it. He doesn't collect anything obvious. He's not going to tell you what he needs because he's already decided he doesn't need anything.
So you're not shopping for a need. You're shopping for a moment — something he'll use, enjoy, or eat. Something that says you thought about him for more than four minutes. Here are the gifts under $40 that have actually worked for me and for people I know.
Food and Drink Gifts
A guy who has everything still eats. And most guys with disposable income don't treat themselves to the good stuff as often as you'd think.
1. A tin of Café du Monde chicory coffee ($9-14): This is the coffee from the famous New Orleans café. It's got chicory in it, which makes it taste different from anything at the grocery store. He either already loves it and will be pumped, or he's never tried it and it's a conversation starter. Either way, $12 well spent.
2. A bottle of Buffalo Trace bourbon ($30-38): Buffalo Trace is the best value bourbon in America. It drinks like a $60 bottle and costs half that. If you can find it — and it's getting easier again — this is a can't-miss gift for anyone who likes whiskey.
3. A tin of Harry & David Moose Munch ($20): Caramel popcorn with chocolate and nuts. It's indulgent, it's good, and it disappears in two days. You're not giving him a decoration, you're giving him a weekend snack.
4. A jar of Mike's Hot Honey ($14): Honey infused with chili. It goes on pizza, fried chicken, biscuits, even ice cream. Guys who cook love this stuff, and guys who don't cook will put it on takeout. It's a $14 gift that gets used up and remembered.
5. A set of four craft beer glasses from Spiegelau ($35): These are the glasses designed for actually tasting beer — not pint glasses from a college giveaway. They make a cheap beer taste better and they look like a serious gift.
Something for His Hands
6. A Leatherman Squirt multitool ($35-40): The Squirt is the tiny one that fits on a keychain. Scissors, knife, screwdriver, pliers — all in something smaller than a pack of gum. Every guy should have one and half of them don't.
7. A tube of O'Keeffe's Working Hands cream ($8): This is the hand cream for people who work with their hands or live in cold weather. It's not fancy, but it works, and most guys won't buy it for themselves. Pair it with the multitool and you're at $43 — split the difference by waiting for a sale.
8. A pack of two Darn Tough socks ($22): These are merino wool socks with a lifetime guarantee. They're the best socks made. He'll think it's a weird gift until he wears them, and then he'll want six more pairs. I gave my dad a pair three years ago and he still talks about them.
Something to Read or Watch
9. A paperback of "The Boys in the Boat" by Daniel James Brown ($13): It's about a rowing team at the 1936 Olympics. Guys who like sports, history, or underdog stories love this book. It's a safe bet for almost anyone, and at $13 it's cheap enough to pair with something else.
want the good stuff monthly?
one short email, no spam.
10. A Criterion Channel subscription for three months ($30): If he likes old movies, the Criterion Channel is the best streaming service for classic and international film. Three months for $30. He can cancel, but most people don't because the library is huge.
11. A topographic map of a place he loves ($25-35): You can order a custom vintage-style map of his hometown, favorite fishing spot, or family lake house from sites like Great River Arts on Etsy. Framed, it looks like a $100 gift. Unframed, it's still a genuinely cool piece for an office or den wall.
Something for the Grill or Garage
12. A set of Grill Grates ($30 for two panels): These are replacement grates that go on top of an existing grill. They sear better and prevent flare-ups. A guy who grills will be genuinely curious about them, and they work.
13. A magnetic parts tray ($10-15): It's a magnetic bowl that holds screws, bolts, and nuts while you work on something. Mechanics use them. It's the kind of thing he'll use constantly and never buy himself. Grab one at Harbor Freight for $4 or a nicer one on Amazon for $12.
What to Skip
Skip novelty gifts — the "World's Best Father-in-Law" mug, the silly sock pack, the golf ball with a joke on it. He has a drawer full of that stuff already and it's all from 2017.
Skip cologne. A man who has everything has a cologne. Giving him a different one is telling him his is wrong, and nobody wants that conversation.
Skip wallets. A man who has everything has a wallet he chose. Your $30 leather one isn't an upgrade.
My One Real Win
Two years ago I gave my father-in-law a $14 jar of Mike's Hot Honey and a $10 magnetic parts tray. Total: $24. He called me a week later to ask where to buy more hot honey and to tell me the parts tray "saved me from losing every bolt on the lawnmower." It was the cheapest gift I gave anyone that year and the only one that got a phone call back.
The trick isn't spending more. It's finding the thing he'll actually use and didn't know he wanted.
